Council Watch · Southwark

Aylesbury Estate: Rebuild, Refurbish, or Both – and Who Pays for the Delay?

By Terrapin Group

Southwark is reconsidering the future of the Aylesbury Estate. Terrapin examines the costs, the options for rebuilding or refurbishment, and what residents need to see next.

Aylesbury Estate: Rebuild, Refurbish, or Both – and Who Pays for the Delay?

Nearly 30 years after Tony Blair stood on the Aylesbury Estate and promised that no one would be forgotten, most of it is still standing. Southwark’s new Green and Liberal Democrat administration has now put the future of the estate back on the table, inviting residents, campaigners and housing experts to a special summit on the options. Those options range from full regeneration to part-rebuild, part-refurbishment, full refurbishment, or routine maintenance only.

The debate is not starting from a blank page. It is starting from a very large bill.

The cost of 20 years

Since Notting Hill Genesis (NHG) was appointed in 2015 Southwark is believed to have spent around £350 million on the regeneration. Less than 1,000 homes have been built by NHG so far, out of 3,575 with planning permission. Here is the uncomfortable part: £350 million is also roughly what it was estimated in 2005 that refurbishing the estate would cost. That comparison will be quoted often in the months ahead, though it is not like-for-like. Building costs, fire safety rules and the condition of the blocks have all changed since then.

Meanwhile, homes sit empty. A council document seen by the 35% Campaign (which has criticised the scheme) counted 974 empty homes on the estate in 2025. The council itself has acknowledged the problem. It has pointed to residents’ concerns about slow progress and antisocial behaviour around empty blocks awaiting demolition.

A partnership already changing

The delivery model was already shifting before May’s election. Southwark’s previous Labour cabinet supported changing the development agreement so NHG could withdraw from the later stages of the project. Under the revised arrangement NHG would complete three sites, bringing its total to 1,664 homes. Control would return to the council, which would look for a new developer to build the remaining 2,200 homes, taking the overall target to 4,200.

So the question for the new administration is not simply “demolish or refurbish?” It is also who delivers whatever comes next, and on what terms.

The case for retrofit, and the case against

Residents are now offering their own answer. In October, a group of residents working with architects Unit 38 launched the Aylesbury Community Plan, promoting a community-led retrofit programme for the rest of the estate. The Green Council Leader, Cllr James McAsh, has spoken about the climate impact and disruption of rebuilding everything, and about making the most of the existing buildings.

The council’s previous Labour administration took a different view. It said retrofitting much of the estate would be “difficult” because of inbuilt problems and new fire safety and building regulations. Without detailed surveys, nobody yet knows who is right. That is the gap the new administration needs to close first.

What residents have always asked for

Residents have rarely been of one mind, but their demands are consistent: certainty, decent homes and a safe neighbourhood. They have also been listened to before, with mixed results. In 2001, the vote on stock transfer and redevelopment saw a 73% turnout, and more than 70% voted against. Four years later the council chose demolition anyway.

What to watch

Three things will tell us whether this reset is real:

  1. Surveys. Independent condition surveys of the remaining blocks, published in full.
  2. Costs. A like-for-like comparison of rebuild and refurbishment, including the cost of further delay.
  3. A decision date. Residents have waited long enough for a timetable.

Will the 50% affordable housing commitment remain throughout? If there are new opportunities for developers, will it be viable for them and for the local authority? Time will tell and Terrapin will keep you informed.

← Back to Council Watch

More from Council Watch